No extension of patent royalty on Spider-Man toy

- Give Up Coffee For Beautiful Breasts
- Welcome to your First Trimester
- Welcome to your Second Trimester
- Welcome to your Third Trimester

Invoking a famous line from Spider-Man lore about great power coming with great responsibility, the United States Supreme Court ruled on Monday in favour of Marvel Entertainment in a patent dispute over a toy that allows users, like the superhero, to shoot webs from the palms of their hands.

Justice Elena Kagan cited the line in explaining why the court, in a 6-3 ruling, declined to overrule a 51-year-old legal precedent concerning patent royalties, rejecting a bid for continued payments sought by the toy's inventor.

The court backed Walt Disney Company's Marvel Entertainment in its legal fight with Stephen Kimble and an associate, Robert Grabb, over royalties on the web-shooting toy called the Spider- Man Web Blaster.

"Marvel is pleased with the Supreme Court's decision, which upholds the court's legal precedent from half a century ago," company spokesman David Jefferson said.

Although the court can overturn its own precedents, this case did not warrant it, Justice Kagan said.

She wrote: "What we can decide, we can undecide, we should exercise that authority sparingly."

She then offered the oft-quoted cautionary line from Spider-Man lore in which the superhero is counselled that "in this world, with great power there must also come - great responsibility".

Mr Kimble had asked the court to overrule the precedent, which said royalty payments generally do not need to be made after a patent has expired, as is the case with the Spider-Man Web Blaster.

Marvel, which has paid Mr Kimble more than US$6 million (S$8 million) over the years to use the patent in the toy, had argued that the precedent set in a 1964 Supreme Court ruling should stand.

Justice Samuel Alito wrote a dissenting opinion noting that the 1964 decision should be overturned because it was "not based on anything that can plausibly be regarded as an interpretation of the Patent Act".

The ruling was "based instead on an economic theory and one that has been debunked", he added.

Mr Kimble obtained a patent for his web-shooting glove in 1991, later assigning it to Marvel in return for a royalty fee.

After he claimed breach of contract in 2008, Marvel argued that the 1964 Supreme Court ruling in the case Brulotte Vs Thys Co involving a harvesting machine meant it would not be required to pay the royalties once the patent expired in 2010.

A federal judge in Arizona agreed.

In 2013, the San Francisco-based 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the decision, saying it was bound by the Supreme Court precedent.

Mr Kimble's attorney could not immediately be reached for comment.

 
Others
 
- Inside Out sets box-office record
- Combs charged with assault
- Hannibal finishing his last course
- Arnie is back as Terminator
- Fifty Shades readers turn writers
- Free Star Wars toys sold on eBay
- Swift's 1989 album not on Apple Music
- New Late Show host Colbert connects via the Web
- One-take thriller Victoria sweeps Germany's Lolas
- Fifty Shades fans mob New York book signing
 
 
 
Youtube channel
Top Search
- Losing Weight In A Week With Honey
- Foods That Cause Miscarriage
- 9 Bad Habits That Can Cause Miscarriage
- Grape Is Pregnant Women’s Friend
- What Is Placenta Calcification
- 7 Kinds Of Fruit That Pregnant Women Shouldn’t Eat
- Do Not Miss Sugarcane Juice In Pregnancy
 
Top 10
- Omega 3 fatty acids – what’s all the fuss about ? (part 3) - DHA supplements
- Omega 3 fatty acids – what’s all the fuss about ? (part 2) - Docosahexaenoic acid
- Omega 3 fatty acids – what’s all the fuss about ? (part 1) - The science bit, Alpha linolenic acid
- Your Pregnancy After 35 : Labor and Delivery (part 15) - When You’re Overdue
- Your Pregnancy After 35 : Labor and Delivery (part 14) - Baby’s Birth Presentation
 
 
 
Recipes
- Healthy Recipes for a Vegan Pregnancy : Sides (part 17) - Caramelized Baby Carrots, Roasted Garlic, Zucchini, and Onions
- Chocolate Covered Naartjies - Cauliflower Carpaccio With Watercress And Almond Dressing - Avocado Mousse Topped With Cauliflower And Bacon Crumbs (part 2)
- RECIPE Orange Cointreau jellies : Golden dessert to beat the glut
- BBQ Chicken Around The World (Part 2) - Beer can chicken
- Healthy Recipes for a Vegan Pregnancy : Vegan Breakfasts (part 8) - Vegan Crepes, Tofu Florentine, Quick Hollandaise Sauc uick Hollandaise Sauce, Potato Poblano Breakfast Burritos
- Midweek Meals - These Dishes Promise Smooth Sailing (Part 2) - Lemon and thyme lamb with warm pumpkin salad
- Grill Happy Healthy Family Dinners (Part 5) - Pork and plum skewers
- Healthy Recipes for a Vegan Pregnancy : Soups and Stews (part 4) - Ten-Minute Cheater’s Chili, Thai Tom Kha Coconut Soup , Cold Spanish Gazpacho with Avocado
- Winter Favourites New Ideas Cooking (Part 2) - Mac ’n’ cheese with pumpkin
- Celebrate Christmas Soon In July (part 2) - Roast pumpkin, fennel & brussels sprouts
- Healthy Recipes for a Vegan Pregnancy : Desserts (part 6) - Foolproof Vegan Fudge, Cocoa-Nut-Coconut No-Bake Cookies , Cheater’s Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes
- Budget Meal Planner For This Week (Part 1) - Monday - Spinach & Sausage Penne
- Budget Meal Planner For This Week (Part 5) - Friday - Rendang Beef Noodles
- Homegrown Treasures Time To Harvest (Part 2) - Beetroot & shallot tatins
- Get To Know Your Salad (part 2) - Greens & Berry Salad